Over the past week I have tried out different ways to write
my journal based on the Reid and Moon framework outlined in the Reader. I have
found this a lot more useful than I initially thought I would. I have found
techniques that really worked for me and discovered issues in my professional
practise that otherwise may not have come to my attention.
“Stream –of-concious writing, in which words are poured out
without pause for punctuation, spelling, or self-censorship, can be of value
here.” Boud (2001)
This is my natural style of journal writing. This is how I
began my journal, I feel it gave me a good start as it allowed me to set up the
purpose of the journal and address what I wanted to get out of the journal. I
thought this would be a good idea over time to see if I kept focused on those
goals that I mentioned.
The first new style I tried out was making a list. In my own personal journals I
often use this technique to set out goals or to compare things. I had never
used it just to map out my day before. I must admit I found it difficult at
first and thought I was writing things that were completely irrelevant. I then
began to see connections between thoughts, feelings and events. I decided to
colour code the list; I highlighted positive things to take forward with me,
things to leave in the past and things to learn from. This way I was able to
reflect on certain feelings or events without writing a huge paragraph about
each of them.
Here you can see how I've highlighted my lists. I have blurred out some of the writing that I didn't want to be seen.
Next I tried writing in a descriptive style, I was surprised in that I struggled with this
one more than I expected to. I wrote down what happened in my day but found it
restrictive to my thinking. I wanted to write what came into my head (back to
the stream-of-concious thought). Although I can see how it would give more structure
to your writing. Reminding yourself when and where you were when something
happened will evoke different memories.
I found the initial
reflection the easiest style to get going with as I think it is closest to
the way I naturally write. I think it was an improvement though as it gave my
writing more structure. I wrote the questions I was asking myself before
beginning my reflection so it’s easy looking back to follow my train of thought.
Writing my journal through a graph or diagram did not appeal to me at all. How could I work
through my issues in this way? Well, easily is the answer. This was the technique
that surprised me today. On that particular day I was not working so I was busy
doing other things. I did a spider diagram for each of the main events in my
day. All of my thoughts seemed to lead back to one thing I was feeling anxious.
If you had asked me how my day went I would have said ‘great’, but by following
my thoughts through the spider diagram you see the underlying pressures that I
have been feeling from various aspects of my life. This was good as it
encouraged me to sit down and plan out my week ahead and be realistic about
what I could achieve, in my lesson plans, reports, uni work etc.
Writing from another
view was fun, I wrote from the point of view of my bag. I picked up on
things like my bag being under strain from the weight of what I was carrying
around – like me feeling anxious about all the work I had to do. As I got the
work under control the day got better and I described how the bag was bouncing
around as I began to walk with a little spring in my step. It also allowed me
to see what others would be seeing of me if they were observing my classes.
I wrote about an alternate day - what if - as if I had just heard that I got an audition for a
fictional acting job. I wrote about the feelings that would create and the
preparation I would have to do. It made me realise that I am missing
performing. I have been so busy and focused with teaching recently I haven’t had
much time to think about it. It also showed that you really are in control of
your own life. You get out what you put in. The only aspect I didn’t like of
this technique is I felt I didn’t reflect on my true day.
Overall I have found this experience rather eye opening. I
think having techniques to work to has made me more aware. It has also made me
think more about who I am writing about – I stop to consider using names before
I just write them. Also on more than one occasion it’s made me question my own
actions, whether I dealt with the situation correctly. Even small things like
children asking you questions not related to drama. You don’t know what their
parents have told them/want them to know, so how involved should you get. One
of my favourite techniques was the diagrams and lists, as they brought out
different points that were not staring me in the face. These techniques mixed
with initial reflection are what I will use going forward. I will use the lists
or graphs to access my thoughts or what I have learnt and then write more in
depth to reflect on that.
References
Boud, D. (2001). Using journal writing to enhance reflective practise. In: L. English and M. Gillen, ed., Promoting journal writing in adult education, 1st ed. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, pp.9-17.
Moon, J. (2004). A handbook of reflective and experiential learning. London: RoutledgeFalmer.
Lisa,
ReplyDeleteI thought this was a very honest account of your journal writing. As I mentioned in my blog, I really struggled with the 'Graphs, Charts and Diagrams' reflective writing. I couldn't comprehend 'plotting' events onto a graph. I had never considered using a mind map or spider diagram to reflect on the day. It seems that you found this form of reflection very useful because it offered a different perspective. After reading you post, I will now trail using a mind map in my next journal entry, as I was unsure how to utilise this type of reflection before.
Many thanks,
Jess.
Hi Jess,
DeleteIn your blog post on 2b you say you found the style from another view most difficult. Why do you think this was? Do you think it's because it's hard to truly understand how others might see us?
I did enjoy this style and did find some interesting points about my day through doing it. But maybe I made it easier for myself by doing it from a point of view of an object. Maybe I should have done it from the point of view of a colleague or a student thus having to be more critical of myself.
Did you try out a mind map how did you find it?
Lisa x
P.S for some reason it wouldn't allow me to comment on your blog post. It said team members only x
Hi Lisa,
ReplyDeleteI think I found it difficult because I couldn't comprehend why my bag or pencil case would have a different perspective on my day. I also found it really difficult to identify an object that I used throughout the whole day because my job is very diverse. I did think it helped me writing from a colleagues point of view.
You make a good point that you can never truly understand how a team member sees you, but it definitely posed an interesting experiences to see how my actions impacted on other staff members. It made me realise I have never considered this in such depth before.
I would recommend writing from a student's or colleague's point of view as you may discover some interesting aspects of your work that you have never considered before. I like how you were creative with this task though, especially as I found it so difficult! If you do try this. Please let me know if you found anything interesting when writing from someone else's point of view?
Yes I tried the mind map last night for my reflective journal. Was a good tool for accessing events that had occurred throughout the whole day and then 'zooming in' and reflecting further on certain events. I am going to post a blog on this in the coming days (when I have time to write up).Thank you for your help on this I may mention your post in my blog if that is ok with you?
Comments should be fixed now. Please comment if you can and let me know if this is working? Thanks for letting me know.
Jess.
It is hard to give objects thoughts and feelings. I know it may sound silly but I tried to think what was that objects purpose therefore what kind of person would it be. What qualities did the object have eg strength, was it old? Older than me? Things like that would affect how it would view me.
DeleteI am going to try again from another view in my journal tonight so I will comment on your blog this time now its working and let you know how I get on :)
Yes that's what I thought the mind map was perfect for. It wasn't enough just to do the map and leave it at that. I have to zoom in afterwards as you say. I have continued to use this style through this week, I find it a good starting point to find out what was the main thing I learned that day. We are so busy and often have many different roles in our lives so I find it helpful to keep my reflection relevant to my professional practise. Although after reading this section of the course almost everything is becoming relevant!
Of course you can mention, not a problem.
Lisa x
Thanks Lisa - I think this relates to that idea of being reflexive - or having a particular position - is power involved? Foucault would say so... Mind maps great - allow yourself to use pictures too - you can always hunt them down in magazines or doodle - and then write over them - words and images to tell the stories/narratives that bring out the ideas.
ReplyDeleteI didn't know of Foucault - looked him up - from my brief look I see that his theories look very interesting. Something I should look into further. I like the picture idea, sometimes they say what we can't. I have started writing quotes in my journal as well that I read or hear that I feel are relevant.
DeleteHi Jess / Lisa,
ReplyDeleteWas just reading through how everyone is writing up their journal writing experience. When I had the Skype with Adesola she made me think of the journal writing in a different way that I had before. I think maybe don't go searching for an answer when writing your journal... sometimes the journal and being reflective can uncover something maybe we were thinking subconsciously that we haven't realised yet. The beauty of it is no ones going to see it, so I've relaxed a bit and let my mind wonder and I think then I've uncovered more from my reflections.
I was just writing in my journal now from the view point of my shoe - seemed as good an object as any! Most of it was just silly, like how my shoes felt not doing a lot of dancing / moving that day. Also, how it felt being superglued together that morning! But some truthful themes came out of it and made me think about how, I really haven't been that productive today and what I'd do differently if I did it again.
Hi Catherine,
ReplyDeleteA few times I have sat down with the intention of writing about a particular aspect of my day and I've found myself writing about something completely different. If you don't mind sharing is there anything in particular that you have found that's come from your subconscious while writing your journal that you think will help your professional practise?
Lisa x